best dump trailer

Comparing Dump Trailers – The Dura-Haul Difference


 “An uncompromised commitment to quality – that is what sets us apart.” 

 

Why Dura-Haul?

At Dura-Haul, we understand that we are not the only option out there. You may ask “Why chose Dura-Haul when there are so many other options to chose from?” The purpose of his post is to answer that question.

What is the best dump trailer on the market today?

 An uncompromised commitment to quality – that is what sets us apart.  While other trailers may come with a smaller price tag, nobody beats our value. While it is easy for us to say things like, “We are the best” and “Nobody beats our value,” those are really just words. They do not mean anything unless we can show you what gives us the right to make those claims. Below is a comparison between one of our trailers and a trailer from one of our competitors. We will not give the name of the competitor, but these specifications were pulled directly from the website of one of the largest dump trailer producers in Canada at the moment. Here you will see the massive difference in what these trailers have to offer. 

dump trailer comparison chart

 

The Dura-Haul Difference

Looking through these specs, there is no question as to which is the better trailer. The purpose of this is not to bash our competition, but rather to show what sets us apart. We understand when it comes to getting the job done right, it is important to have equipment that will work hard for you and last. That is the Dura-Haul Difference.

gooseneck vs bumper pull trailer

Gooseneck Or Bumper Pull?


 

Bumper Pull Vs Gooseneck Trailers: Which Is Best For You?

Many different factors come into play when deciding on a new trailer. Bumper and gooseneck trailers are often compared to each other as they can serve similar purposes. However, the differences between the two types of trailers will help you decide which design is best for your personal situation. In the following article, we’ll look at 6 aspects to help you decide whether a bumper pull or gooseneck trailer is best for you.

  1. Consider Your Load Size

The scope of your cargo plays a vital role in which type of trailer is best for you. For smaller, sized loads, bumper pull trailers offer ease and convenience. The reverse side of that coin is that with a bumper pull, the weight of the trailer is resting on the very back of the truck, which is less efficient than a gooseneck. If you need to move large loads, you may need to take advantage of a gooseneck trailer. One of the benefits of using a gooseneck trailer is weight distribution. Placing the load over the rear axle instead of on the bumper means that your truck does not need to work as hard to carry the weight of the trailer and its contents. This will lead to a smoother ride, better fuel efficiency and less wear on your truck.

  1. How Far Do You Have To Drive?

Before making a final decision on the type of trailer you need, it’s important to map out your journey. If you’re working in the city travelling short distances, bumper pull trailers are a convenient option. If your journey requires highway driving, it’s worth considering a gooseneck trailer. Because bumper pull trailers are attached only to the trailer hitch, it becomes difficult to recover from weight shifting around or if your vehicle begins to swerve. Gooseneck trailers latch over the top of your vehicle’s rear axle, which helps transfer excess force to the ground. This is a feature that helps you stay safe when moving at highway speeds and while on roads with lots of curves and turns. When travelling long distances with heavy loads, gooseneck trailers are the safer option.

  1. Do You Carry The Same Materials All The Time?

The type of materials you haul plays an important role in which type of trailer is best for you. Having the wrong type of trailer can create unnecessary issues that you’re forced to address while on the job. As previously mentioned, bumper pull trailers are great for small loads that aren’t too heavy. If you consistently transport the same types of items, a bumper pull trailer will probably work fine. However, if the contents of your cargo can change without notice, a gooseneck trailer is a more versatile option. Because gooseneck trailers are longer, they make it easy for you to transport awkwardly shaped loads.

  1. What Kind Of Truck Are You Pulling Your Trailer With?

Your vehicle plays an important role in the bumper pull versus gooseneck trailers debate. The biggest advantage of a bumper pull trailer is vehicle compatibility. Bumper pull trailers are connected to the trailer hitch and are easily towed by any truck with the appropriate towing capacity. On the other hand, gooseneck trailers are attached directly to the truck bed, which does have a few drawbacks. One, you lose the use of your box or bed; two, you need a truck that not only can handle a gooseneck (usually, you are looking at a ¾ or 1 ton), but also has a built-in gooseneck hitch. The type of vehicle your company uses on a daily basis will help you decide which trailer is the most convenient.

  1. Where Will You Be Parking?

Security is an important aspect to consider If you have to park your trailer outside. As previously mentioned, gooseneck trailers can only fit on certain types of vehicles. This alone makes your trailer significantly more difficult for people to steal. With a bumper pull trailer, all the thief needs is a hitch on their truck. You can also use a lock to secure your trailer to the hitch.

Bumper pull trailers tend to have a shorter overall length than goosenecks, which is a plus when it comes to parking space. As mentioned previously, they are also compatible with a lot more vehicles. This is something you will be grateful for when you need to move a parked trailer and someone else is out on a job with the only truck with a gooseneck hitch.

  1. Which Trailer Is Easier To Maneuver?

This is a major point in favour of goosenecks. While many people are intimidated their first time backing up with one, a gooseneck is much easier to maneuver for an experienced driver than a bumper pull.  For one, it is easier to see where the trailer is going with a gooseneck, but the big advantage is the turning radius. With a bumper pull, you only have so far you can turn before you are crushing your truck’s bumper.  With a gooseneck, you can safely have your trailer at a 90 degree angle to your truck in most cases. This offers a major advantage when it comes to making sharp turns and parking in tight spaces.

Which Trailer Is Best For You?

In short, there are many pros and cons to both bumper pulls and goosenecks. It is not as simple as one being better than the other. We hope this article helped explain what you need to be looking for when choosing the type or trailer you are purchasing.  For information contact us anytime – we are always happy to help find the trailer that best suits your needs.

choosing the right dump trailer

How To Choose The Right Dump Trailer


So what needs to be considered when we are choosing our dump trailer? There are many factors.  Below, we will go over the main ones including: bumper pull vs gooseneck, size, weight, durability, and features for various types of jobs.

1. Dump Trailer Size

To determine the size required, we first need to consider what we need the trailer to accomplish. If we are using it to haul machinery, obviously, we need to make sure that the machinery will fit in the trailer. For example, if we need to haul a John Deer 26G excavator we look at the transport length and track width (which are 13 ft 9 in and 4 ft 11 in), we know that the Dura-Haul 7×14 dump trailer can handle this no problem with the interior being 14ft by 7ft.

If we are looking at hauling materials (gravel, dirt, garbage, construction waste), we are probably thinking about trailer size a little differently. In this case we are thinking more in terms of volume rather than length and width. For example, if we need to move up to 15.5 cubic yards of gravel, the Dura-haul 14ft dump gooseneck high-side would be a great fit. However, if we only need a capacity of 7.71 cubic yards, we can downsize to the Dura-Haul 14ft Bumper Pull or the Dura Haul 14ft Gooseneck with low sides.

2. Weight

When choosing the right trailer for the job, we need to think about how much weight we need to move, what our truck can handle and what our trailer can handle. GVWR stands for Gross Vehicle Weight Rating which is the maximum amount of weight your trailer can be when fully loaded. So GVWR – trailer weight = maximum payload (assuming your truck can handle at least as much as the trailer).

When hauling heavier loads, it is important to make sure your whole trailer can handle it.  Often times, the listed GVWR is mostly based on what the axles and tires can handle. So it is possible you could end up with a trailer with two 7,000lbs axles but a weak channel or tube frame and insufficient bracing under the bed.  This will be a problem down the road if you are consistently hauling 10,000lbs loads.

3. Bumper Pull or Gooseneck?

Both options have their advantages and disadvantages. We will not go too deep into that here as we already have an entire article on the topic which can be found by clicking below. Examples of considerations discussed in this article are: turning radius, weight distribution and truck compatibility.

gooseneck vs bumper pull trailer

Gooseneck VS Bumper Pull

4. Build Quality

This is one of the most important considerations. We need to make sure that our trailer can handle what we are throwing at it and be reliable. Buying a cheaper trailer may save you some money upfront, but if you are constantly dealing with repairs and downtime, those savings will disappear very quickly.

Materials and design play a big role here.  One thing we want to look at is the gauge of steel used. For the floor of the trailer, common gauges used are 7 gauge (3/16 inch) and 10 gauge (9/64 inch).   7 gauge is used for heavy duty trailers whereas 10 or 11  gauge may be used for lighter duty smaller trailers that don’t take as much abuse.  Some manufacturers will use 12 or 14 gauge for the flooring – this tends to be a red flag.  The advantages of a lighter gauge are cost savings and reducing the overall weight of the trailer, but this comes at the cost of durability.

The frame is very important when determining whether or not you have a strong trailer.  Many trailers are built with tube or channel frames, which offer little structural integrity compared to I-beam.  I-beam is a vertical piece of steel welded to two horizontal flanges. This allows optimal handling of vertical and horizontal stress.

DUMP TRAILER, BEST DUMP TRAILER, SURE TRAC, SOUTHLAND

Another major factor when considering the durability of our trailer is the finish. The common options are paint and powder coating. Paint is cheaper, but powder coating is far superior as it is highly resistant to chipping, scratching and wear. This will mean that, not only will your trailer look better, but more importantly, it will be much more resistant to rust, therefore will last longer.

There are many other factors when considering the build quality of a trailer including bracing/cross-members, quality of components (like the lifting mechanism, and battery), suspension and more.  However, this should give you a good idea of where to start looking.

Comparing Dump Trailers

5. Functionality

Size, capacity and quality are fairly obvious considerations when choosing a dump trailer, however, we also need to think about whether or not we have all of the right features we need to get the job done.  Here are a few examples:

Spreader gate – if we are using the trailer to spread gravel or other materials, we need to make sure that it has a spreader gate. This is where the back of the trailer opens at the bottom only to control the amount of material coming out.

dump trailer spreader gate

AC Charger – If we cannot always rely on having a truck nearby to charge the battery, we probably want to be sure that we have an AC/DC converter built in so that we can charge off an outlet.

Heavy Duty Fenders – If your job requires you to climb onto the sides of the trailer regularly, you want to make sure that you have steps and/or fenders that can support your weight. Many trailers are built with very cheap flimsy metal fenders so this is something to watch out for. (many dump trailers do not have this, all Durahauls do).

Dual Acting Hydraulic Unit – If speed and time efficiency are important to you, a dual acting hydraulic unit is probably something that you want. What some people may not know if that many hydraulic trailers are not equipped with a hydraulic up and hydraulic down.  With a single acting hydraulic unit, the pump is used to move the trailer up but to move the trailer down, it relies on gravity alone.  This means longer weight times when lowering your trailer.

Ramps – If you are buying a dump trailer, chances are, you need ramps.  You may not be regularly loading an excavator or ATV, but even if it is not part of your regular work day, ramps will be something worth having at some point.durahaul heavy duty ramps

Connection Points – This is something that can be overlooked when choosing a dump trailer. If you are loading any kind of equipment into your dump trailer, you need to have something you can attach straps or chains to like D-rings.  If you are stuck without these, you may find yourself in a situation where you cannot properly secure your load which will create issues with safety and the DOT.

14K 7x14 Heavy Duty Dump Trailer

Final Thoughts

There is a lot of information here, all of it relevant when choosing a dump trailer. It is important to know that not all dump trailers are alike, every make has their differences. The best first step you can make when choosing the right trailer is choosing The Dura-Haul Difference, an uncompromised commitment to quality. Call us today so we can help you find the trailer that is right for you.

Contact Us Today!